Sam & Freddie’s First & Last Kisses ?? - iCarly - #TBTCarly or Sam? Some fans say that Freddie's one true love was always Carly, after all, she kissed him in the finale episode right as she was leaving for Italy. It had to mean something right? Well, not according to Seddie shippers. They think that Carly was just a childhood crush and Sam was Freddie's true love.
Carly gets a crush on Freddie because he saves her life and is injured himself in Season 3 | Episode 9 . [Sam is trying to warn Freddie about dating Carly]. After the events of "iLost My Mind," Sam and Freddie begin a rocky relationship. At the near end of the episode, Freddie and Sam go on a date, but take Carly. We STILL can't get over that Sam and Freddie are dating! NEW iCARLY in 2 DAYS!" to promote the episode. Sam and Freddie are dating in this.
We didn't really have to act that much But the beats and the feeling were all pretty authentic. It definitely made things a little bit teenage levels of awkward.
The main thing that showed that is that we really didn't have that many episodes devoted to it. There was the one episode with Carly and Freddie where Freddie saved her life and that was their main thing.
Then Sam and Freddie had this arc of three or four episodes. But besides that, we didn't want to laser in on that being the point of the show. Nathan: "I think it was more of a chemistry thing. You'd have to ask Dan Schneider or one of the writers to see if that was more of an overarching thing that they were planning on, but because there was so little of that kind of dialogue and those kinds of moments that would have made you wonder in the first season, I think it was something that just sort of evolved.
Just to kind of keep the mystery alive. And I think it would have been a bad time for there to be a lot of focus on that. Because when it came down to it, it was about the friendship. Nathan: "I guess it was kind of trippy thinking about how the universe had expanded to something else and we were being talked about in the context of another cast. It was nice because it kind of took the pressure off. This wasn't an iCarly reunion where all eyes were on us and, "Is this going to be the funniest episode of iCarly ever?!
Nathan: "It's weird, I was thinking about it this morning, what it would be like for us to do a reunion episode? Because honestly, as tempting as it is to get the band back together and do all that stuff, I think all of us would probably be just a little bit worried that the expectation would be so impossibly high that we would never be able to satisfy everyone.
Because it wouldn't just be bringing iCarly together — it would be bringing iCarly together to make an episode better and funnier than any iCarly episode that was ever made. That's the only way that people would say the reunion was worth it.
That's the problem. As much as people say they would want it to happen, I don't know if that's necessarily true just because it would be so sad for our last thing to disappoint people. It would really come down to an outrageously good script. However, Freddie tells her she has no problems and she decides to leave.
Meanwhile Gibby comes face to face with a man named Caleb, a patient who is said to be from the year Sam then tries to leave but the security guards keep her since she is under 18 and needs a parent to sign.
Although, Pam Puckett is away in Tijuana getting laser hair removal. The gang needs to start iCarly the next night but the security guards have never heard of it.
The guards keep Sam there and throw Carly, Freddie and Gibby out. Then, they try to get Spencer to play Sam's mother. But the plan backfires when a patient recognizes Spencer from law school. Spencer tries to keep his identity a secret but the plan backfires when he snaps at the patient to stop pulling his wig.
The gang then decide to do the webshow from the mental hospital. Freddie tries to tell how he feels about liking Sam and a bunch of other Seddie fans such as the Seddie yeller from "iStart a Fan War" also tell their feelings. Sam then begins yelling at Freddie but he kisses her mid sentence. After the events of "iLost My Mind", Sam and Freddie begin a very rocky relationship, but problems circulate around Carly when she has to intervene and resolve their every argument even one at 3 am.
Meanwhile, Gibby finds a puppy and he wants to share it with Carly, in an attempt to get closer to her. At the near end of the episode, Freddie and Sam go on a date, but take Carly with them to resolve a fight if they get into one.
After Sam and Freddie criticize each other, Carly intervenes and says that if they do not control every argument then they should not be dating. Gibby tries to break up Sam and Freddie, as Sam now uses him as a target for her violent tendences. He recruits Carly, who is unsure about whose side to take even after Sam and Freddie fail to attend an iCarly shoot, leaving her to and Gibby to run the show single-handedly. He also recruits Mrs. Benson, by telling her that her son is dating Sam.
Meanwhile, Freddie's application to "N. Camp" is rejected, which, unknown to him, Sam trashed the application. Benson comes to the studio and shows him the application.
When he threatens to dump Sam, Carly finally snaps and rushes up to the studio and smooths out the argument. Gibby also snaps and drags Mrs.
Benson out of the studio and sings a love song to celebrate Freddie and Sam not breaking up. Meanwhile, Freddie gets Spencer to lie to Mrs. Benson in order to cover his relationship with Sam.
Spencer, tired of lying, finds himself attempting to open a bakery from the Shays' loft in order to make his lie the truth. Carly convinces Sam and Freddie to try each other's hobbies. Freddie takes Sam to his train engineer club much to her dismay. Meanwhile, Spencer's past babysitter arrives and starts to treat him like a 4 year old.
Because of this Carly gives the two a talk about if they like each other they should act like it. Sam and Freddie overhear and take Carly's advice. While in the elevator they admit that they love each other but end up breaking up and deciding to re-break up at 12 since it was onlyand they kiss as the elevator closes and the episode ends.
Sam and Freddie help Carly to impress her latest crush, Kyle, by being smarter than she is through studying habits.
However, she soon decides that since she can't remember all the things she studied, she needs to look over information so she decides to write notes on her arm, and regain information from the Internet. However, when she does this in the middle of her date with Kyle, she gets caught, which leads into Kyle breaking up with her for being dishonest. Benson's loft, but must be a person that Mrs. Benson would accept, leading Freddie and Sam to change him up for his interview. On the other hand, Spencer tries to open a safe he found at the junk yard.
An exception being Noah Munck, who Rex treats as a god amongst men.iCarly - iWant to Date Freddie - Nickelodeon UK
As victims of her crime, the iCarlys have a say in whether or not Nora should be released from prison. They decide to let them release her, and after Nora and her mother invite the iCarlys to their house for a Norwegian supper, the iCarlys become on friendly terms with Nora once again.
However, when Spencer comes to pick them up, Nora's mother locks him in the basement on a spin wheel which is controlled by a special remote.
Nora and her mother trap the iCarlys in their house and refuse to let them leave. Nora says that her birthday party will go on "forever, and ever, and ever The next morning, Nora's dad returns from his camping trip and becomes part of the scandal.
The fifth season of iCarly began airing on Nickelodeon on August 13, and finished its run Carly then ends up being dragged into a dinner date with Sam and Freddie but gets really upset when she has to sit at a table by herself. In the next episode, Carly suggests that Sam and Freddie try each other's hobbies, but. Icarly episodes when sam and freddie are dating. Discover ideas about Icarly Sam And Freddie. Icarly iwill date freddie watch online. Icarly Sam And. At the end of the episode, Sam asked Freddie out to dinner showing she still has . In iDate Sam & Freddie, Sam and Freddie go on a date in a purple booth.
Meanwhile, T-Bo is kicked out of the Benson's apartment after Mrs. Sam: But I wasn't ripping on a guyI was ripping on you. Sam: I know what I want to do when I look at you. And that was really personal, and I shouldn't have said it on the show. Yeah, that's right, I've never kissed anyone. Which is a bad idea unless you live near a hospital! Freddie: I was just gonna say Sam: That we should kiss?
Freddie : You're gonna break my arm now, right? Sam: No. Freddie: Well should we? Just so both of us can get it over with? Sam: Hmm Freddie: Just to get it over with. Sam: And you swear we both go right back to hating each other as soon as it's over? Freddie: Oh totally, and we never tell anyone! Sam: Never! Sam: Well Sam: [Looking dazed] Nice? Freddie: Yeah, nice um Sam: Good Freddie: [hurriedly] Thank you, you too.
Freddie: [calling after Sam with a smile as she climbs over the window-ledge] Hey, I hate you. Sam: [chuckles] Hate you, too.
Sam: Okay just… forget it Sam: Because I came here. Have I ever come to you for help before? For anything? Freddie: What did you do to my locker? Sam: My locker! Freddie: Our locker! Sam: When did you turn into my wife? Sam: [chewing] Want a salami? Freddie: [jokingly] No thanks, Princess Puckett! Carly : Why didn't you tell me you and Freddie kissed? Sam : [shocked and at a loss for words] Freddie : [opens the door with a cable in his hand] Hey, can I run upstairs for a second and install these ca-- [sees Carly and Sam - stares at her with a shocked face] Sam : [with an angry look] You spoke of it!
Freddie : [throws cable in air screaming and is chased out of the room by Sam who is also screaming] Sam : [carries Freddie back inside and throws him on the couch, then hurries and locks the door] Sam : [in a hurt tone] You swore you'd never tell anyone we kissed!
Carly: I'll turn my back, and you guys can resume kissing behind it!
Carly: How long was it? Sam: What? Carly: How long did you guys kiss? I don't know. Sam: Like Freddie: [nods] seven Carly: Oh. And was it fun? Sam: [gives Carly a look] "Fun".?
Carly: Yeah, I mean Spencer runs in, leaving the question unanswered] iThink They Kissed. Sam and Freddie: What?! Sam: [slaps Freddie] Freddie: [slaps Sam] iCook. Sam: Dude, we have got to stop doing that. Sam: She's not in love with you, she's in love with what you did!
Freddie: You just can't stand the idea of Carly and me as a couple! Sam: Very true, it makes me wanna puke up blood. But still Freddie: Aw Sam. Sam: Nyeeh! Freddie: Nyeeh!
Freddie: [to Spencer] I don't go out with girls I've never met! Sam: [walking past him] Well, no girl you have met's gonna go on a date with ya. Freddie: I'd be more offended if I knew what a "stub-rag" was. Sam: C'mere. She stuck her tongue in my ear!!! Sam: Yeah, lucky you. Sam: Freddie, come rub my neck. Freddie: sarcastic Yeah, that'll happen. Freddie: [to Carly] You literally jump into bed.
Sam: I wanna try it! Freddie: And look who's late again! Sam: Don't start with me! Sam : Show them the prank, Fredwiener! Freddie : Sure thing Sam : And that's why you're behind the camera. Freddie: Say it! Freddie : Wanna putt some meat? Sam : Yeah, I'll play some meat golf. Sam: You have got to try this Fat Shake!! Sam [to Cort, excited] : You got the job! Freddie : But What about Brad's fudge?!
Remember the fudge! Freddie: [in a vampire voice] Whenever you're ready. Sam: It doesn't work on us! Freddie : [pulls Sam aside] Okay, what's up with you?
Sam: What do you mean? Freddie: [firmly] You have been nice and helpful and considerate all day - what's your game? Sam: [flatly] No game. Freddie: [relenting] Okay. Sam: Okay? Freddie: Okay. Sam: Okay. Sam: Oh, man up. Or at least boy up. Sam : Why'd you come here?
Freddie : To figure out why you checked yourself into a mental hospital. Sam : You wanna know why? Freddie : Kinda. Sam :Because I hate you! Freddie : Then why'd you kiss me?! Sam : Because I Freddie : So, you hate me and you like me? Sam : Now you see why I need to be in here? I got problems. I can't think straight, I can't eat, I--I-- Attendant : Sam, we have hot quesadillas-- Sam : [shuts the door and starts eating a quesadilla] Freddie : Look Sam, I get that you're feeling a little-- Sam: Aww, who cares, so I kissed you.
It doesn't matter 'cause there's no way I'd ever go out with you or be your little girlfriend and Freddie : Can I have one? Sam: No! Freddie : [to Sam] Look c an we talk about the kiss? Sam: Yeah, actually let's never talk about it, alright? Freddie: Sam Freddie: [takes his hand off her shoulder] You're not any more mentally unstable than you have been your whole life.
Sam : You really mean that? Freddie : I do. Sam : 'Kay Freddie : Good. Freddie: Okay, I wanna know Sam : Whatchu wanna know? Sam : Okay, remember the time I pushed you in front of that bike messenger and he knocked you down and hit your head on that fire hydrant?
Freddie : [smiles] Yes Sam : Well afterwards, when you were laying there, moaning Freddie : Yeah? Sam: I dunno, you looked, kinda cute. Freddie : Aww, [rubs his ear] then it was worth the hearing loss. Sam : Well, yeah Freddie : Yeah. Sam: After I get some ham. Freddie : Some things more important than ham! Sam: [menacingly] Don't you ever say that to me Freddie: I think that's fair.
Sam: [sighs] Dittyo. Sam and Freddie : [smile then kiss] Freddie: [grabs Sam's hands] Let's go get you that ham. Sam: Aww, Baby. Freddie: Hey, how great does Sam's hair look?
Sam: He brushed it for me. Freddie: With one of these. Freddie: Hey, Cuteness. Sam: Lips, please. Sam: [to Freddie, cloyingly stroking his chin] C'mon, don't be mad at Mama. Carly: [to Freddie] Sam loves you!
Freddie: [turns to look at Sam] She wasn't talking about us. Sam: [shrugs] I know Freddie: Well I mean Sam: [scoffs] Hey, you put me in a mental hospital. Freddie: [looks at Sam and nods his head at her] And fun. Sam: [smiles] Yeah, I just Freddie: Yeah Sam: Oryou get a little more abnormal [Freddie and Sam look confused] Freddie: Feels like it Sam: Yeah Freddie: [smiles at Sam] Fair enough. Sam: [shrugs] Oh well Sam: [walks up to Freddie and kisses him sweetly] Freddie: [takes his PearPhone out of his back pocket] It's only Sam: [smiles at Freddie] Wanna break up at midnight?
Freddie: That works. Sam: OK [Sam and Freddie go back in the elevator; Sam pushes the down button, smiles, and starts kissing Freddie again; and the episode ends with the elevator door coming down, as they continue kissing].
Freddie: Careful, Sam, those are sharp! Sam: [walks, over to couch, pats Freddie on the knee] Freddie: [laying down on the couch, sad] I just wanted people to think I was creative. Sam: And I wanted a mom without stretch marks, but that ain't happenin'. Freddie: [sits up] What do you mean? Sam: [moves hand while she speaks] Ya know, weren't you working some sort of Freddie: Yeah, I was trying to figure out a way to shoot video, so people can watch online in 3-D [gesturing to his eyes] without special glasses.
Sam: [smiles] See, that's creative. Freddie: But, I never could make it work. Sam: Well, you know Freddie: [finishes her sentence] I should Sam: [nods] Yeah Freddie: [talking about Harry Styles being sick] Sam: [sounding disgusted] You did not just say that. Freddie: [sipping his smoothie] I did, and I'm proud of it. Sam: [pointing to where Carly had gone] You got a new little crush on her? Freddie: [scoffs] No!
Freddie: Bye! Freddie: [Walks over to and stares at Sam] Sam: What are you looking at? Freddie: Your costume I don't get it. Sam: I'm hand sanitizer. Freddie: Ohh, I mean does it Sam: Here, pump my head.
This doesn't smell like hand sanitizer. Freddie: You did not Freddie: How did How could you Sam: You wanna finish any of those sentences, or? Sam: We sorta dated for a while He's still in love with me, it's kinda sad. Sam: [going after Freddie] Dude! Natalie: Don't you Ehh, who cares? Sam: [thinking for a second] Yeah Natalie: I'll never see you again, will I?
Sam: [without turning] Nope! Sam: T-Bo has been pretty whazzed off lately. Freddie: [shrugs, looks at her] He lives in the same apartment as my mom. That would whazz a guy off. How do you do it? Sam: Years of practice. It takes a lot of mouth coordination to totally master the chicken wing bite, scrape, and slurp.
Sam: Uh-oh. Freddie: What? Sam: [sing-song] He's gonna do something bad to your fooood Freddie: [imitating Sam's sing-song manner] No, he's 'nooot'. Carly: He's not gonna do something bad to Freddie's food.
Enjoy your chili fries. Freddie: I will.
Sam: After he blows his nose on them. Freddie: Dangit, Sam! Sam: It the laptop was a Bat Mitzvah gift from my Grandmother. Freddie: You're not even Jewish. Sam: [grabs Freddie by the collar, pulls his face up to hers so their noses touch] You tell my Grandma that and I will break you. Freddie: [nervously] Shalom! Sam: [on the phone to Freddie] I have to talk to you about something important. You wanna get back together?
Do you? Freddie: [nervously] It's just that What's up? Note that she mentioned dinner at the Bensons. She doesn't like it but she probably had dinner at the Bensons when Carly was in Yakima or that whole afternoon she spent with him because no one came to pick her up. These are the first four episodes we filmed of the new iCarly season. During production, the writers and I often heard from the staff and crew, "These may be the best iCarly iCarly episodes we've ever done.
Oh, and if you're a "shipper" — don't go freakin' out on us! In the dialog of the video you hear Freddie say, "Slapping my head isn't going to make the chip stop working" Carly adds "What would? Since then, many of you have been asking if the Sam-Freddie storyline will continue. The answer to that question is… YES! It's a subtle thing, but I do it because I feel it gives the scene a sense of reality you often don't see in a sitcom.
Dinner Date Who would've thought? Sam and Freddie eating dinner together without any insults or bruises? We can't believe our eyes! Smoochy Sweethearts Seddie locking lips?!
This couldn't be MORE adorable! Sippin' Smoothies What's a couple in love to do other than sip on a delicious Groovy Smoothy? Puppy Love It looks like Sam and Freddie aren't the only ones in puppy love! Starry-Eyed Nothing shines brighter than a lady in love!! We know Well get ready to catch those Z's because we're finally gonna find out what happens next! Has Sam gone totally bonkers or is Seddie about to be named the new "IT" couple? We'll find out in August! Don't worry guys. And we promise, it'll be totally worth the wait.
We just can't wait to see what happens next! Sign In Don't have an account? Start a Wiki. Contents [ show ]. Categories :. Hints of attraction iPilot Sam beats up a boy for insulting her, but when Freddie insults her, she does not do anything violent to him, possibly indicating some early feelings Sam had. When Sam and Freddie first appear together, they immediately call each other by name, showing that they knew each other before iCarly.
Sam ignored what Freddie is saying to her by "blah-ing" at him, which he soon gets fed up with and starts doing back at her. Freddie becomes upset when Sam tells Carly that he wants to be their "geek".
Briggs can "poke an eye out with those things". Sam goes into Freddie's apartment and drags him into Carly's apartment by the leg, while he screams in protest. Freddie made a remote that he gave to Sam, not to Carly. Freddie wasn't happy when Sam didn't say "please" to him.
Sam tells Freddie to turn the camera to himself and say "yo to the people. Freddie and Sam argue and bicker a lot in this episode. Freddie kept on rubbing it in Sam's face that he and Spencer were winning in their attempts to get more viewers for iCarly.
Sam looked upset whenever Freddie would say "In your face! No offense, Carly.
iDate Sam & Freddie
When Carly goes to answer the door, they hold each other's glares. Freddie repeatedly tries to retort to Sam's comments which leads to their bickering. It took Carly spraying them with water to get them to stop. While the trio is watching the dance videos, Freddie agrees with Carly, and Sam says, "Weird you'd agree with Carly" sarcastically, and Freddie responds with, "Weird you'd say that.
Freddie and Sam are lying against one another at some point during the couch montage, and when they realize it, they awkwardly pull away.
It is notable to say that when observed, Sam didn't want to pull away at first, and only pulled away when Freddie nudged her off. This may indicate some early feelings that Sam has.
She also looked a little disappointed when she finally moved away. At first, on the couch, the three sit in the order Sam, Carly, and Freddie. However, when it is indicated that some time has passed, they are sitting in the order Sam, Freddie, and Carly. It makes you wonder what happened, and how Freddie and Sam ended up beside each other.
He also explains what that finale kiss between Freddie and Carly was all I got the chance to chat with the director of the episode and iCarly.
Freddie is jealous when Carly and Sam talk about how hot the blonde guy is. While Freddie is asleep, he remembers a comment Sam made about the guy saying, "That boy's got moves. Sam and Freddie both agree that Jake is terrible, and they kept smiling at each other, saying, "Check! Sam sounds genuinely interested in why Freddie was saying "Check! Freddie and Sam both agreed that Jake was horrible and shouldn't sing on the show.
While talking about what they should improvise about during Jake's time something funnySam mentions to Carly that they should talk about Freddie's haircut. Sam wonders to Freddie why her grandfather just sleeps and burps when Carly's grandfather comes in, and Freddie replies because he's related to her.
Sam sticks popcorn in Freddie's nose in response. Freddie is seen standing very close behind Sam. Both Freddie and Sam become really excited to go buy smoothies. Sam doesn't listen to Freddie when he tells her to keep her hands off his equipment and just keeps playing with it to bother him.
Freddie says that Sam's butt is shaped like a ham. That would mean that he has been looking at her butt. While they are leaving the studio when Carly's grandfather arrives, Freddie keeps looking back at Sam as if she'll do something to hurt him. Both of them leave Carly's apartment through the back door together. At Carly's locker, Sam retorts to Freddie about standing up to Carly's grandfather, possibly showing jealousy. Sam tells Freddie he's "Yaka-mannoying. Sam pulls Freddie off of Carly.
When Mrs. Benson tells Spencer that he had to stop rubbing anti tick lotion on Freddie when the fire happened, Freddie notices Sam come over and tells his mom he doesn't have ticks.
Sam and freddie dating episodes
Sam teases Freddie about the anti tick lotion which he retorts is precautionary. When Freddie grabs Carly's grandfather's leg yelling "Thank you! This could imply that Sam is getting frustrated with Freddie's obsession with Carly. When everyone is down in the lobby after the fire, Sam walks in and says that Freddie sent her the text saying that there had been a fire. It might be awkward to Creddie fans that Sam is sitting beside Freddie.
Freddie seemed excited to help Sam "do bad things" to the girls who thought iCarly wasn't worth checking out because it hadn't been reviewed by Nevelocity. Sam pushes the cart Freddie was in in the direction the girls walked away in. When Freddie asks Carly to kiss him, Sam rolls her eyes, obviously annoyed by Freddie trying to get Carly to like him. When Nevel walks past Sam and Freddie, just before they sneeze on him, Nevel seems to look at Sam the same way he looked at Carly, and Freddie seems to look jealous.
After Sam jumps off the sofa saying "You keep making out with your stuffed animals," Freddie stands very close to Sam, nearly putting his arm around her. After hearing Spencer scream about Toasty the BakerFreddie and Sam run over to him and stand shoulder-to-shoulder looking at the melted butter. Sam blames Freddie for turning down the temperature in the apartment which causes them to start arguing. Benson walks into the Shay ApartmentFreddie looks back at Sam as if he's embarrassed at what she'll say about his mom.
Freddie whacks Sam on the arm and glares at her while Sam seems unaffected by it. After Mrs. Benson leaves, Sam teases Freddie saying "cool mom" while he just knelt his head. After Freddie says he is going to establish a connection between his camera and laptop, Sam comments, "Wow, a tech-talkin' witch boy.
Look out ladies! When Freddie is expecting to be insulted by Sam when she comes in the building, she looks at him and simply says " Too easy. Sam asks Freddie if she can make it look like she's standing on his face. Freddie angrily asks Sam why she must always attack him with words and she retorts if he'd rather have him attack him with rocks. Freddie says Ms. Briggs probably spits on puppies when she's at home and Sam nods at this, then asks Carly why that would make a good idea for their web show when she brings it up.
Sam makes fun of Freddie's spy-pie and makes fun of the fork as well. When Sam calls Carly and Freddie when they are stuck in Ms. Briggs' apartment, Freddie seems excited when Sam calls and seems intent on the conversation on the phone. When Sam gets to Ms. Briggs house and hears the bagpipes, she looks appalled at the thought of both Carly and Freddie being tortured by Ms. Sam notices the pie on the ground and calls Freddie stupid for thinking his spy-pie would work.
Freddie looks angry when Sam offers him to pay for the dented bagpipes but doesn't say he won't pay for them. When Carly pushes Sam and Freddie into the hallway, Sam and Freddie look at each other when Carly mentions the green screen.
Also, Sam looks at Freddie during most of the time during that part. While putting things on the greenscreen during Ms. Briggs performance, Sam glances over at Freddie and giggles.
When iCarly get their audience back, Sam and Freddie smile at each other and fist pound. Sam rolls her eyes goodnaturedly after Freddie shows her and Carly the Randy Jackson cologne and says "it smells tight, dawg. Sam seems pretty angry when Valerie says that Freddie is cute, and she also seems to hate Valerie from the start, just because she says she likes Freddie. Sam rubs Freddie's stomach as a joke when she says "Date the dork. Note that Sam gave her this look before she found out Valerie was trying to steal Freddie from iCarly.
Sam says, "I will give a thousand bucks just for one picture of Freddie's butt. While Freddie is on his date with Valerie, Sam gets Carly to spy on them with a hidden cam. Sam sets up the camera herself and seems to be pretty good with technology and knows how to use Freddie's equipment. Sam along with Carly laughs at one of the jokes Freddie makes on his date. If Freddie could see or hear her she wouldn't laugh but possibly insult him.